Saturday 7 June 2014

WATCHING THE RELEASE OF BOWE BERGDAHL





The watcher sees 1:53 of a 17 minute film.

It is on



and other websites, including YouTube.

It is not a trailer, more a single in a mini-series. It is an incident in the movie of our world, echoing many of the existing images, texts, songs and movies of our world.

The watcher sees a white man, clean-shaven and bare-headed, sitting in a pick-up truck, possibly a Toyota Land Cruiser. The mise en scène is dusty scrub-land, desert, modern-day outback. The watcher wonders if this is Arizona.

The truth is that reality takes too long to put on screen.

The man seems calm in a close up at 0:18. He speaks to another man, who leans in the window of the open door of the vehicle. This other man wears a head scarf. Another man, similarly dressed, standing off, carries a machine gun.

Don't make programmes for your eyes only – that's the province of some experimental 'art' directors. But do make programmes that you want to make and you yourself want to see. There's not much point doing it if your hearts not in it.

A voice-over in a language the watcher cannot understand – Dari? Pashto? Arabic? - runs from the start. A logo, such as appear on TV news channels, is seen in the top right hand corner of the screen.

At 0:31 the bare-headed man stands outside the vehicle. He is guarded by men with their heads covered, a number of them carrying guns. The camera pans upwards to a cloud-filled sky. The watcher hears and sees the distinctive sound and silhouette of a US-built Black Hawk military helicopter.

The camera moves and sweeps across the ground. There is a cut at 0:42 and the helicopter lands in a cloud of dust. The Black Hawk is down, yet safe.


The voice-over ends and, from this point on, the audio is provided by the rotating blades and the stuttering engine of the Black Hawk. The camera leaves the helicopter and, at 0:50, the watcher sees one of the cowled men carrying a stick with a white cloth on it.

The watcher wonders at the origin of this gesture. There are many songs about it, including religious ones.


The watcher is not sure if singing songs about crosses, war, surrender to a god, while waving white flags, is helpful.

The breaking of weapons and other such gestures often accompany scenes like these. The watcher remembers the films Broken Arrow and The Battle of Apache Pass.



The watcher senses we could be in Arizona in the late 19th Century.


At 0:54 the bare-headed man is led forward. Three men, dressed in civilian clothes, come from the helicopter. They raise their palms in pacifying gestures of greeting. They extend their hands and these men cautiously shake hands with the guarding men. The bare-headed man is passed to the three from the helicopter, who lead him away. Uniformed soldiers receive them.

The bare-headed man is patted down at 1:25 and they are all helped aboard. It is a comically tense moment.

In the end directing video and film is selecting your version of reality and putting it on screen. To paraphrase Degas, the Impressionist artist: it's not what you see that matters-it's what you make others see.

The helicopter rises off the ground at 1:45 and clatters through the dusty air. Two men dangle their feet over the edge of the side doorway of the helicopter. They wave at the people on the ground.

The helicopter bears the number is 41. It's close, but not the ultimate answer.

"The Answer to the Great Question …" "Yes ... !""Of Life, the Universe and Everything ..." said Deep Thought. "Yes ... !""Is ... " said Deep Thought, and paused. "Yes ... !" "Is ... " "Yes ... !!! ... ?" "Forty-two," said Deep Thought, with infinite majesty and calm. … "Forty-two!" yelled Loonquawl. "Is that all you've got to show for seven and a half million years' work?" "I checked it very thoroughly," said the computer, "and that quite definitely is the answer. I think the problem, to be quite honest with you, is that you've never actually known what the question is."

The watcher knows that the images are from the point of view (pov) of a man on the ground. The watcher is confident there is a camera on the helicopter, taking images from the Black Hawk's pov.

The camera can't be objective either. Someone has to operate it and operating it involves choice, choosing where to put it and which way to point it and when to start and stop it and what to leave out as the action develops.






Directing on Camera: Harris Watts; book; Aavo Media; London; 1992
The Hitchhiker's Guide to The Galaxy; Douglas Adams; Pan Macmillan; London; 2009




www.facebook.com/DaveDugganWriter




No comments:

Post a Comment