The
recent state visit by The President of Ireland to Britain highlights
many facets of the relationships between the peoples of the two
adjacent western European islands.
No,
it's not much. Just a place and some memories and time passing into
ever shortening futures. But you survived, too. You're a survivor.
In
particular, it highlights the opening line of L.P. Hartley's novel,
The
Go-Between
The
past is a foreign country. They do things differently there.
The
most excitable reaction to
the presidential visit
from the London media was to the attendance at a dinner in Windsor
Castle of Martin McGuinness. He
is
Deputy First Minister of Northern Ireland and formerly a leading
figure in the Provisional Wing of The Irish Republican Army, a
decommissioned anti-state military organisation.
The
same London media outlets who focused on Martin McGuiness'
attendance and his past also frequently carry stories and opinion
pieces in which the people of Northern Ireland are urged, entreated
and exhorted to move on from the past and move its legacy from
current events to history.
They forget that
the past is multiform and is forever present. The past is eternally a
current event, held in many different views. The London media view,
though dominant, is only one such view.
There
is no go-between to negotiate the troubled past of a conflict in
which thousands of people lost their lives over four
decades and which is rooted in colonial relationships between the two
islands over
many centuries.
The
remarks of former London government Minister Norman Tebbit, in which
he looked forward to the occasion when a dissident republican would
shoot Martin McGuinness in the back of the head, illustrate the pain
victims of violence experience on a daily basis, long after the
tragedy that was visited upon them has past. His remarks do not
illustrate the grace of other victims of violence associated with the
conflict in Northern Ireland, as offered by people such as Gordon
Wilson and Kay Duddy. The reaction of victims of violence are as
varied as the persons themselves.
I'm
a survivor. I survived. Through all the pain, anguish, hurt, grief,
history, time and blood. I survived. That's my legacy. Your legacy
too.
Norman
Tebbit's remarks and the focus of the London media on Martin
McGuinness' attendance underline just how difficult and painful the
legacy of the past is.
Simply
asserting that it must be dealt with is not enough. The legacy of the
past is a site of continuing contestation. It need not be violent, but
it is a struggle and it is painful.
Arriving
at a
set of agreed understandings
of the nature
of the
conflict may not be possible. For some it was a terrorist, law and
order matter. For others, it was a war of defence, survival and
liberation.
Look,
war is about targets. Collateral damage. Lists getting longer. They
do this, we do that. One of ours, one of theirs. Some in uniforms,
some in civvies, Some legitimate, some illegitimate …
All
dead.
All
dead. The lowest common denominator. The bottom line.
If
it became
possible to agree such a frame-work of understanding, then it might
be
possible for state and non-state combatants to acknowledge what they
did. And from such acknowledgements, may come genuine justice and
possible prosecutions. Or amnesties, if agreed by citizens.
No guarantee.
Simply calling on victims to 'move on', particularly when such calls
come from the power centre of one of the main protagonists in the
conflict, is not sufficient. It feels like the victims, the
foot-soldiers, the dead and the maimed must 'get over it' on terms
that suit and do not disturb the powerful.
The
bomb didn't start it. Talk started it. And talk will finish it.
And
new games, with new rules. If we can find them.
Genuine attempts
to create processes and practices to resolve matters from the past
are grounded in the truth that it is indeed another country, though not a foreign one. We can visit it with open-eyed and generous-hearted wisdom. And with an
assertion that things will be different. So different that the new
past we now make will not be the same as the old one we made.
It's
very hard.
It
is. We'll always be waiting.
Waiting
….. :
Dave
Duggan; stage-play; 2000; from Plays
in a Peace Process;
Guildhall Press; Derry; 2008
The
Go-Between: L.P. Hartley; novel; Penguin Modern Classics; London; 2000
www.facebook.com/DaveDugganWriter
Excellent review. I disliked this film quite intensely. I felt it explored every negative Irish stereotype possible....with nothing positive to say about us native Irish...apart from stunning scenery!
ReplyDeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteGood note. Thanks.
ReplyDeleteIt refers to the piece called WATCHING CALVARY.